Castaways Pizza & Grill is a welcoming pizza restaurant in Conneaut, OH, where great food, friendly service, and a comfortable atmosphere come together to create a dependable dining choice for locals and visitors alike.
Conveniently located at 877 Broad St, this casual and cozy spot is built for everything from a relaxed lunch to a satisfying dinner, whether you are stopping in for a solo meal, gathering with friends, or looking for an easy family-friendly option.
With a strong 4.30-star rating from 688 reviews, Castaways Pizza & Grill has earned a solid reputation for delivering a consistently enjoyable experience that keeps customers coming back.
What makes this restaurant especially appealing is the way it combines convenience, variety, and quality. Guests can choose from dine-in, outdoor seating, takeaway, delivery, or on-site service, making it easy to enjoy a meal in whatever way fits their day.
The menu goes beyond pizza to include comfort food, quick bites, small plates, coffee, beer, wine, and alcohol, giving customers plenty of options for lunch, dinner, dessert, or a casual drink.
Known for fast service, a great beer selection, and local specialties, Castaways Pizza & Grill offers more than just a meal—it provides a dependable place to unwind, enjoy good food, and feel right at home.
Accessibility and ease of visit are also clear priorities here. The restaurant offers wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating, and toilet access, helping make the experience comfortable and welcoming for more guests. On top of that, payment is simple and flexible with acceptance of credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
With table service, counter service, restroom access, and a laid-back, quiet setting, Castaways Pizza & Grill is designed to make every visit smooth, satisfying, and memorable. For anyone in Conneaut looking for a trusted pizza restaurant that pairs quality with convenience, this is a place that delivers on all fronts.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Castaways Pizza & Grill
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Hear from our valued guests
Definitely my new spot, been in this county 3 years and every week I go out and try out what our local restaurants offer, my biggest peep is the wings, if you can't cook them as I order them, then on to the next restaurant. I Definitely give this place 10 stars out of the 5 Google gives you the option to. Very friendly environment among the guests, and Ashley made sure everything was ok....!!!!
First time having Castaways. Ordered 2 pizzas, one Pepperoni and one Chicken BBQ. We got it to go and it took 30minutes and that is what they said it would take. Very friendly and helpful staff. Pizzas were very tasty. The BBQ was better than I expected. Had a light bbq with a white cheese like sause...not sure what it was but it was good. Kids liked the pepperoni. 2 slices were plenty for each of us. We will eat there again...and again. Oh and they are Sponsors for our daughter's basketball team. Thank you!
Let me see 🙈! My last meal was an, OPEN face BARBECUE BRISKET SANDWICH 🥪 🤤😋! My previous meals: 5. Spaghetti 🍝😋! 4. EGGPLANT 🍆 Parmesan, w/Mozzarella Cheese! 3. Spaghetti 🍝😋! 2. LAKE ERIE PERCH Sandwich 🥪😋! 1. I ALWAYS ORDER THEIR SLICES, OF CHEESE PIZZA TO GO! Let's just say,"I love their food 🤤😋!!! The meals are very filling! THEY SERVE LARGE PORTIONS!!! YUMMY 😋 🤤 FOR MY TUMMY!!! I recommend everyone eats GOOD FOOD, at CASTAWAYS PIZZA 🍕 and GRILL Castaways is owned by, a Wife and Husband Team, Consisting of Criss and Scott! They cook Great Italian/Italiano food. I usually come to Castaway's Pizza & Grill, When, visiting City Auction House, Auto Auction, West Springfield PA. Or anytime, any day, after the auction.
This place is absolutely amazing whenever we go the food is just beyond incredible!!!!! Especially the admiral you want a hearty sandwich that is definitely it !!!!! I would add pictures but don't know how to ..
We’ve been working up in Conneut for a couple of weeks driving up from Hudson everyday and we’ve had lunch from here a few times! Absolutely amazing food! Hot and fresh everytime. And inside is a very cool atmosphere! Very clean also. And very friendly staff! Will be back if we’re out this way again! :)
They have good sandwiches and burgers. Both visits we enjoyed. The space in dining room and restroom was lacking a bit for using my rollator. I had to collapse it before getting into the restroom. Service was fast and friendly both visits.
I absolutely love their food. I wish Lake County had a good restaurant like this. Their pizza crust is premium. The shrimp corn chowder is the best. Their Godfather and admiral subs are huge. And I've never seen any other restaurant have these. I wish I didn't live 45 mins away.
My mom and I went on a quiet day some Mondays ago. Small quaint seating and outdoor tables as well. Had laughs with her watching Family Feud on the televisions while drinking our beers and eating some great burgers and Rueben sandwiches. To be honest I've lived here all my life and have never gotten food from Castaways but I'll definitely be craving some sandwiches from them now. See you soon!
Stopped in the past weekend as our last stop on a Conneaut Pizza Crawl! It did not disappoint. Got a couple beers which they had a huge selection and a simple pepperoni pizza as we were comparing 6 of the local spots in 1 day! The vibes were as it was fully decorated for the holidays (I own a restaurant and tried to decorate all out but this was awesome will be borrowing some ideas for next years inspo). Can’t wait to make it back again and try!
Just moved to conneaut this year and have heard about the great pizza places in town. I wanted to try them all and this is most definitely a great option. I have tried 3 so far (JDs, Conneaut pizza & subs, and castaways) and this was definitely "next level". called in for a pickup order and the service was friendly. Got a big 18" alfredo pizza with pepperoni and it was real good even reheated. Garlic bread was nothing crazy but complimented the pizza well. I have yet to try the other places that ive heard are "the best in conneaut" but this place is pretty darn good.
Common questions about Castaways Pizza & Grill
Castaways Pizza & Grill is located at 877 Broad St, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States, Conneaut, OH, United States.
You can reach Castaways Pizza & Grill by calling +1 440-599-8187.
Castaways Pizza & Grill has a rating of 4.3 out of 5 based on 688 customer reviews.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible seating, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following service options: Outdoor seating, Delivery, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following highlights: Fast service, Great beer selection, Serves local specialty.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following popular for: Lunch, Dinner, Solo dining.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following offerings: Alcohol, Beer, Coffee, Comfort food, Quick bite, Small plates, Wine.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following dining options: Lunch, Dinner, Counter service, Dessert, Seating, Table service.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following amenities: Restroom.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following atmosphere: Casual, Cozy, Quiet.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following crowd: Tourists.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following children: Good for kids, High chairs, Kids' menu.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following parking: Free parking lot, Free street parking, Paid parking lot, Plenty of parking.
Castaways Pizza & Grill features the following pets: Dogs allowed outside.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
